Main Content

Home » Must-try restaurants near Westhampton Beach

Must-try restaurants near Westhampton Beach

There are many perks to living in Westhampton Beach — miles of beautiful beaches, great vistas, and friendly people. And if you love food, you’ll be glad to know that the area offers some of the best dining experiences in Suffolk County. To whet your appetites, book a table at these excellent restaurants:

Dee’Angelo’s Pleasant Ave Café
149 Main St.

If it’s Italian soul food you’re after, then Dee Angelo’s is the place to be. This beloved restaurant has been operating for over 20 years, serving top-notch Italian favorites such as pizzas, pasta, veal cutlets, osso buco, and more. You can also enjoy your pizzas al fresco at their outdoor patio.

Brunetti Pizza
103 Main St.

Brunetti is an authentic Neapolitan-style restaurant operated by father-and-son duo, Michael and Jason Brunetti. They use a proprietary dough recipe that results in a crust that’s delicately crisp outside but chewy on the inside. The original restaurant in Westhampton Beach now has another branch in West Village, Manhattan.

Simon’s Beach Bakery Cafe
112 Main St.

Have a taste of Europe at this hometown favorite on Main Street. For over 30 years, Simon’s Beach Bakery has served fresh bread, cakes, pastries, and coffee. It is Westhampton Beach residents’ go-to place to grab a snack.

Boom Burger
85 Montauk Highway

The best burger is one you can build yourself, and Boom Burger lets you do just that. Diners here can choose exactly what goes into their burger, from the patty to the garnishes. Everything here is cooked upon ordering so you can be assured that you get your food hot and fresh. Other must-tries include their Philly cheese steak and hotdogs.

295 Montauk Highway

Brewology marries the art and science of craft beer, a concept exemplified by their Periodic Table of Beers. Executive Chef Chris Zullo’s menu complements the 30-plus beers on offer. The great food here is cooked with only the finest local ingredients.

1 North Steakhouse
322 W Montauk Highway

Craving for some USDA Prime beef? Then 1 North Steakhouse is the place to be. It serves a variety of steaks like filet mignon, rib eye, porterhouse, and strip steak. The cuts may be ordered plain, marinated, or dry-rubbed.

Villa Paul
162 W Montauk Highway

Villa Paul has become one of the areas most renowned Italian-American restaurants, boasting specialties such as Long Island duckling, marinated steak, and fresh local seafood. It also serves signature Italian dishes.

Stone Creek Inn
405 Montauk Highway

The historic home where Stone Creek Inn is located was renovated in 1996 by Chef Christian Mir. Its modern French-Mediterranean menu and award-winning wine list have made it a beacon of the local culinary scene.

Buoy One
62 Montauk Highway

Seafood doesn’t get fresher than at Buoy One. The restaurant is casual, friendly space that offers market-to-table seafood. Diners rave about their lobster dinner, shrimp dishes, and fresh fry baskets.

The Westhampton area has a rich food landscape that’s sure to tantalize any foodie’s taste buds. For more about the local lifestyle, get in touch with Kerrigan County Realty, a leading boutique real estate agency serving the Hamptons, the East End of Long Island, and North Fork. Call 631.288.9600 or e-mail and let our expert team assist you.